Plum Creek Farm Market & Creamery

Jess Millard a month ago

Came for breakfast a little after 9:00. Ordered two bagels with cream cheese, chipped beef on toast, baked oatmeal with milk (took to go), a caramel iced latte, chocolate milk, and an apple juice. I usually love coming here for breakfast, but I was highly disappointed today. The chipped beef was extremely disgusting. It was super runny, hardly any beef, and what beef was there, tasted like rubber. I asked them to please remake it, and it came out exactly the same. Toast was burnt and the cream had way too much pepper. Not like what I’ve had before. Iced latte was okay, but I couldn’t taste any of the caramel syrup. The bagels looked pretty basic, with only one small thing of Philadelphia cream cheese.

DGP 3 months ago

Plum Creek Farm Market & Creamery is a wonderful place to visit! The farm market offers a great selection of fresh, high-quality local products, and everything we purchased was excellent. The ice cream was absolutely delicious—rich, creamy, and full of flavor, with plenty of great options to choose from. The staff was warm, friendly, and welcoming, making the whole experience even better. The peaceful farm setting adds to the charm and makes it a perfect stop for families or anyone looking to enjoy fresh treats and local goods. Highly recommend visiting Plum Creek Farm Market & Creamery—we’ll definitely be back!

Michele Ford 5 months ago

Very family/ kid friendly with a fantastic outdoor seating area and play area. There is amble seating indoor and outdoor. It can get very busy but the service is quick. The food is average at best. The ice cream is ok- not the best and not the worst. It is unclear if they make the ice cream. It is unclear the ingredients of the ice cream.

M W 6 months ago

We had a great experience here! Despite visiting on a busy weekend, the food came out fast & was delicious. The kids meals are an especially good deal ($7) and come with two sides & a drink. Don’t skip the soft pretzel

ang 10 months ago

ok so starting off with the market side, its actually really good i wish i can rate that separately that would be a 5/5 stars they bake their own stuff it looks like and it was amazing, me my friend and my husband got the lemon bar, dehydrated marshmallows that look like lucky charms, pumpkin whoopie pie, and chocolate chip whoopie pie and everything was good but the marshmallows. they kinda tasted stale so i was very disappointed but still, the desserts were amazing. now for the restaurant side.. dont be fooled by the pictures, the pictures really does it justice but you will be pooping in the bathroom for over a hour and have a horrible stomach ache ALL 3 OF US HAD A STOMACH ACHE AND WENT TO THE BATHROOM FOR OVER A HOUR, I AM ACTIVELY WRITING THIS ON THE TOILET if you want to be in the bathroom for hours then come here i guess they have really good presentation but that doesn’t make up for the taste the tenders tasted weird but great honey mustard sauce the classic burger was meh the other burger i think it was called blue marsh or plum creek, one of those we think the meat might of been undercooked because he had the worst stomach ache out of all of us the coffee was defin